Choose one of the following topics to analyze in a thoughtful, well-developed essay over one or both of Tim O'Brien's stories that we read. Obviously, if you can develop a full essay based on evidence and analysis of only one story, that's fine; you may, however, use both stories to provide adequate examples and explanation if necessary.
1. In Tim O'Brien's stories of the Vietnam war, storytelling is used more as a means to convey ideas, release emotions, and reflect on action that has taken place than to entertain. Explain this statement, elaborate on its meaning and support it with examples and explanations from one or both stories. Consider the significance of storytelling to these storytellers.
2. Like life, war is a paradox. Identify at least three or four of the most significant examples of paradox from in one or both of Tim O'Brien's stories. In what way is each conflicting statement true? What is O'Brien's point in using these paradoxes? In what way is truth itself, at least in O'Brien's work, a paradox?
3. A catharsis refers to a release of emotions (often sadness, pity or fear) that would otherwise be suppressed. In many cases, a catharsis allows an individual to feel cleansed or purged of detrimental emotions and better able to continue his journey. While all the members of Alpha Company experience the sudden, violent deaths of their fellow soldiers, it is necessary for a number of them to take action that allows them to release their grief, anger, and heartbreak. Who are they? What actions do they take? Are their actions beneficial to them or the rest of Alpha Company? Explain. Explain. Explain.
4. What is it that Rat Kiley, Mitch Sanders and the narrator seek in the stories they tell of Curt Lemon, the men in the mountains, and the war? What are these men looking for in an audience (or reader)? Why is "listening" so important to all three men?
No comments:
Post a Comment